Injured? Dial #WIN or #946 from your cellphone for your free consultation or call 1-800-LAW-NEED.
Call Us 24/7
( 1-800-529-6333 )
Click to Call 24/7

Michigan Supreme Court Decision on Case

July 20, 2020

MICHIGAN- The Michigan Supreme Court recently held that work performed by subcontractors that is unintentionally defective may be considered an “accident” for the purposes of commercial general liability (CGL) coverage in Michigan. The work can, therefore, lead to valid claims made under subcontractor’s insurance coverage.

The decision ends a $1.4 million lawsuit stemming from faulty subcontractor work performed on an HVAC system in a medical center. The subcontractor reportedly incorrectly installed the expansion joints. The mistake caused damage to various parts of the structure, including the heating system and concrete.

The insurance company rejected the contractor’s claim stating that the issue was not an “accident” based on the subcontractor’s CGL policy. In the policy itself, the company had neglected to define “accident.” The court found that the incident would qualify as an accident.

The court also stated, though, if the policy specified that defective work would not be covered, then the decision would not apply. 

The decision is viewed as an indication that Michigan is a business-friendly state. The ruling is in line with similar decisions made in several other states, including Georgia, South Carolina, Florida, Mississippi, Indiana, and Texas. Federal courts deciding cases in Arkansas and Minnesota also issued rulings in line with the Michigan decision. However, a federal court came down with a different ruling in a case based out of Missouri. The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals stated that construction defects are normal for the industry, and cannot be considered unexpected, which the term “accident” implies. 

Put Our Law Firm's Legal Experience To Work For You! We Know What It Takes To Win!™

While we hope you are safe and never need our services, our Accident Lawyers are here to help you if you are involved in any type of accident or just have a question.  Call Montlick & Associates, Injury Attorneys, for your free consultation today. Our law firm has been representing those who suffer serious injuries for over 39 years and our attorneys have recovered billions of dollars in compensation for personal injury claims and collision lawsuit settlements for our clients. We Know What It Takes To Win!

If you are having trouble obtaining compensation for medical bills, lost wages, rental car reimbursement, and other accident-related costs from the at-fault drivers insurance company adjuster, call to learn about your rights. 

No matter where you are located our lawyers are just a phone call away, and we will even come to you. Call us nationwide 24 hours day/7 days a week for your Free Consultation at 1-800-LAW-NEED (1-800-529-6333), or simply dial #WIN (#946) from your mobile phone. You can also visit us online at and use our Free Case Evaluation Form or Free 24-hour live chat.


Category: Personal Injury

Please Note:
All information provided by our blogs is general in nature and should not be relied upon as legal advice. Consult a Montlick attorney for details about your unique situation.

We have updated our privacy policy. By continuing, you are agreeing to our terms.